Good Girls Season 5: Cancellation Explained

In the world of television, fans often find themselves emotionally invested in their favorite shows, eagerly awaiting each new season to dive back into the lives of beloved characters. One such show that captured the hearts of many viewers was “Good Girls,” a crime comedy-drama series that followed the adventures of three suburban mothers turned criminals.

However, the excitement turned into disappointment when news of the show’s cancellation broke. In this article, we’ll delve into the curious case of “Good Girls,” exploring the reasons behind its cancellation, the cast’s reactions, and the hopes of its dedicated fan base.

The Premise and Popularity of “Good Girls”

“Good Girls” is an American crime comedy-drama series that revolves around the lives of three suburban mothers who, out of desperation, turn to a life of crime. Created by Jenna Bans, the show featured a talented ensemble cast, including Christina Hendricks as Beth Boland, Retta as Ruby Hill, and Mae Whitman as Annie Marks. These three women, facing various personal and financial struggles, decide to rob a supermarket. What follows is a rollercoaster of events as they become entangled with the FBI and a crime boss.

The show’s unique blend of crime, comedy, and drama struck a chord with viewers, earning it a dedicated fan base over its four-season run. With each episode, the audience became more invested in the characters’ journeys, eagerly anticipating the resolution of numerous storylines.

Anticipation for “Good Girls” Season 5

As the fourth season of “Good Girls” concluded, fans were left with a multitude of questions and unresolved plotlines. The anticipation for a fifth season was palpable, and viewers hoped to see their favorite characters confront new challenges and adventures.

In March 2021, as the fourth season came to a close, there was no official announcement regarding the release date for “Good Girls” Season 5. However, fans speculated that it might arrive in late 2023 or early 2024. Their advocacy for the show’s continuation was a testament to the strong connection they had with the series.

The Cancellation Bombshell

Amidst the excitement and anticipation for “Good Girls” Season 5, a bombshell dropped on fans and the cast. During an episode of “Live With Kelly and Ryan,” Retta, one of the show’s stars, revealed the shocking news of the show’s cancellation.

“We were very close to a fifth season, but one person ruined it for all of cast and crew and so it’s not back,” Retta disclosed.

This revelation left fans and viewers puzzled. Who was this mysterious person, and how had they managed to derail the show’s continuation? Kelly Ripa, the co-host, inquired why this individual couldn’t be replaced, to which Retta responded, “It was a little too close to when they would have to start and figure out the story.”

Fans’ Reaction and Speculation

Naturally, fans were both disappointed and curious about the circumstances surrounding the cancellation. Retta’s revelation ignited a flurry of discussions on social media platforms. Many fans questioned the decision not to replace the problematic individual and explored various theories about what had transpired.

Retta herself expressed her frustration, saying, “Trust me, Kelly! I’m salty!” She even humorously suggested an outlandish scenario involving a bomb scare and an actual explosion as a reason for the person’s departure.

However, Retta did not disclose the identity of the person responsible for the show’s cancellation, leaving fans with more questions than answers.

Behind-the-Scenes Insights

To gain a deeper understanding of the cancellation, it’s essential to consider some behind-the-scenes factors. Last July, TVLine reported that NBC had unofficially decided to renew “Good Girls” for a fifth and final season, with production tentatively slated to begin in spring 2022.

As part of the deal, all three leading ladies—Christina Hendricks, Retta, and Mae Whitman—had agreed to take a pay cut to ensure the show’s continuation. However, despite these efforts, the show ultimately met its demise. An NBC insider cited “financials” as the stumbling block, indicating that the network couldn’t make the numbers work.

Another source close to the network mentioned “creative issues” as a factor in the cancellation. This vague term left fans speculating about the creative differences that might have led to the show’s premature end.

The Enigma of Manny Montana

One aspect that garnered attention during the cancellation saga was the role of Manny Montana, who portrayed the enigmatic character Rio on the show. Reports hinted at scheduling and financial issues concerning Montana as a potential contributing factor.

While Montana’s representatives remained tight-lipped about the situation, his involvement—or lack thereof—in Season 5 added another layer of complexity to the show’s cancellation.

Unresolved Storylines and the Future of “Good Girls”

One of the most significant sources of frustration for fans was the prospect of leaving numerous storylines unresolved. As “Good Girls” Season 4 concluded, it left several critical questions hanging in the balance.

  • Rio’s Fate: One of the central mysteries revolved around Rio’s potential release from prison. Fans were eager to discover whether he would return to the criminal world or pursue a different path.
  • Stan’s Lost Funds: Another unresolved storyline concerned Stan’s financial troubles. Would he and Ruby find a way to recover from their financial setbacks?
  • Beth and Dean’s Marriage: The tumultuous relationship between Beth and Dean had been a focal point of the series. Viewers were invested in whether their marriage would endure or crumble under the weight of their complicated lives.
  • Annie and Gregg: Annie’s budding romance with Gregg introduced a new dynamic to the show. Fans were curious to see how their relationship would progress.

The Future Possibilities

While the cancellation of “Good Girls” was undoubtedly disappointing, there are still glimmers of hope for fans. Although nothing has been publicly confirmed as of now, there remains the possibility of the show finding a new home on a different network or streaming platform.

Should the series get a second chance, it could pick up where Season 4 left off, diving into even riskier escapades and criminal endeavors for Beth, Ruby, and Annie. Fans would finally get the chance to see the resolution of lingering plotlines and character arcs.

Furthermore, a potential Season 5 could introduce intriguing new characters and plot twists, keeping the audience engaged and eager for each new episode.


The cancellation of “Good Girls” was a heartbreaking blow to its dedicated fan base, who had eagerly anticipated the continuation of their favorite show. While the exact reasons behind the cancellation remain shrouded in mystery, it’s clear that a combination of financial challenges, creative issues, and behind-the-scenes complexities played a role.

Despite the disappointment, fans can still hold on to the hope that “Good Girls” may one day return to their screens, bringing resolution to the unanswered questions and delivering more thrilling moments from their beloved characters. Until then, the legacy of “Good Girls” lives on through its existing seasons, streaming on platforms like Netflix, reminding viewers of the quirky, crime-filled world that once captivated their hearts.

Scroll to Top