Barbecue Showdown Season 3 Review: Is the New Season Worth Watching?

The latest season of Barbecue Showdown has landed on Netflix, inviting fans back to the smoky, flavorful world of pitmasters vying for the title of American Barbecue Champion.

Known for its blend of fierce competition and friendly camaraderie, the show spotlights talented backyard smokers and pitmasters as they battle it out with their grilling skills.

But with season three now available, is it worth watching? Let’s break it down.

Bringing Flavor and Fun in Barbecue Showdown

Season three of Barbecue Showdown delivers the familiar, addictive mix of high-stakes cooking and lighthearted fun. Hosted by Michelle Buteau, who brings her characteristic humor and charm, the season keeps audiences engaged with its welcoming atmosphere. Buteau’s playful interactions with contestants and judges help keep the tone relaxed even when the heat is on.

The judging panel is led by Melissa Cookston, a Mississippi-born barbecue chef, and Kevin Bludso, a pitmaster from Los Angeles. Together, they bring their expertise to a competition that tests nine contestants’ barbecue prowess as they compete for a $50,000 grand prize through a series of tough challenges.

One of the standout aspects of Barbecue Showdown is its unique focus on the challenges of cooking in intense heat, often requiring contestants to balance multiple cooking surfaces simultaneously. This adds a distinct twist to the usual cooking show formula, showcasing the adaptability and versatility required of these pitmasters. Contestants are expected to not only deliver flavor but also display resilience and creativity as they navigate demanding conditions.

The competition format remains consistent with previous seasons, featuring barbecue staples that are familiar to fans. This sense of familiarity resonates with viewers, making the show feel like a celebration of American barbecue culture rather than just a contest. The authenticity of the dishes and the stories behind each one enhance the appeal, inviting fans to imagine the tastes and smells of classic barbecue favorites.

The Highlight of the Season

Michelle Buteau, who fans might recognize from The Circle, shines as the host of Barbecue Showdown, with her witty commentary and approachable style adding an extra layer of enjoyment to the show. Her one-liners bring levity to the competition’s tense moments, helping keep things entertaining.

Judges Kevin Bludso and Melissa Cookston maintain a rigorous standard. Their feedback is balanced, alternating between constructive criticism and enthusiastic praise. This approach allows contestants to feel supported while still pushing them to do their best. When dishes excel, the judges don’t hold back on their appreciation; but when things go wrong, they offer unfiltered critiques, providing valuable insights that the pitmasters can take to heart.

A notable highlight in season three is the appearance of guest judge Matty Matheson in episode five, a recognizable figure for fans of The Bear. Matheson, who has experience running a pop-up called Meat + Three, brings an additional layer of expertise and passion for barbecue to the judging panel. His knowledge and enthusiasm enrich the dynamic, adding a fresh voice and perspective to the competition.

Stories of Passion

The contestants this season bring diverse backgrounds and styles, with each pitmaster contributing their own flair to the competition. Among them, Sloan Rinaldi stands out as an inspiring figure, having discovered her love for barbecue later in life. Her story embodies the idea that it’s never too late to pursue a new passion, adding an emotional layer to her journey through the season.

The finale sees Gerald Vinnett and Shaticka Robinson competing for the championship title, with Shaticka ultimately taking the win. A professionally trained chef with a profound love for barbecue, Shaticka’s journey resonates with viewers. Her dream of opening a barbecue joint named Coley’s Jook Junt gives a personal and heartfelt conclusion to her story, celebrating her dedication and skill.

Conclusion

Season three of Barbecue Showdown stays true to the elements that made previous seasons a hit. While there are few changes to the format, the contestants’ passion and skills, along with the familiar faces of Buteau, Bludso, and Cookston, keep the show engaging. The addition of new talent like Matheson on the judging panel injects fresh energy into the competition, keeping it lively and dynamic.

The relatable dishes and the contestants’ dedication to the craft of barbecue make Barbecue Showdown more than just a cooking competition. It’s a love letter to barbecue culture, filled with warmth, intense rivalry, and a strong sense of community. Fans of food competitions will find season three worth watching, as it delivers a satisfying blend of high-stakes cooking, honest judging, and heartwarming moments that celebrate the passion behind great barbecue.

Scroll to Top