Gel vs Liquid Eyeliner: Which is Better?

When it comes to eyeliner, there are two popular types to choose from: gel and liquid. Both have their advantages and disadvantages, and it can be difficult to know which one to choose.

In this article, we will compare the two types of eyeliner and help you decide which one is better for you.

What is gel eyeliner?

Gel eyeliner is a creamy, usually water-resistant formula that comes in a pot or a tube. It is applied with a brush, and it can create a bold, precise line. Gel eyeliner is usually more pigmented than liquid eyeliner and is ideal for creating a dramatic look. It is also easier to smudge, making it perfect for creating a smoky eye.

What is liquid eyeliner?

Liquid eyeliner, on the other hand, is a thin, liquid formula that comes in a pen or a brush applicator. It creates a sharp, defined line that dries quickly and stays in place all day. Liquid eyeliner is perfect for creating a crisp, precise line and is great for achieving a natural look.

Pros and cons of gel eyeliner

Pros

• More pigmented
• Easier to smudge
• Ideal for creating a dramatic look
• Lasts longer than liquid eyeliner
• Can be applied with a brush, giving more control

Cons

• Can be difficult to apply for beginners
• Can dry out quickly
• May smudge or transfer on oily skin
• Can be time-consuming to apply

Pros and cons of liquid eyeliner

Pros

• Creates a sharp, defined line
• Dries quickly
• Lasts all day
• Ideal for achieving a natural look
• Easy to apply

Cons

• Less pigmented
• Difficult to smudge
• May crack or flake if not applied correctly
• Limited control due to the pen or brush applicator
• Can be difficult to remove

Application of gel eyeliner

To apply gel eyeliner, you will need a brush. Dip the brush into the gel eyeliner pot and wipe off any excess product. Starting from the inner corner of your eye, use small, short strokes to apply the eyeliner along your lash line. You can create a thin or thick line, depending on your preference. For a winged liner, use the brush to create a flick at the end of your line.

Application of liquid eyeliner

To apply liquid eyeliner, shake the pen or brush well before use. Starting from the inner corner of your eye, use small, short strokes to create a thin line along your lash line. You can create a thicker line by layering the product. For a winged liner, draw a diagonal line from the outer corner of your eye towards the end of your eyebrow. Connect the line to your lash line, creating a triangle shape. Fill in the triangle with the eyeliner.

Which is easier to apply?

Liquid eyeliner is generally easier to apply than gel eyeliner because of its pen or brush applicator. The formula is thin and liquid, allowing for smooth and effortless application. On the other hand, gel eyeliner requires a brush and a bit more practice to master. It can be challenging to create a precise line with gel eyeliner, especially for beginners.

Which lasts longer?

Gel eyeliner usually lasts longer than liquid eyeliner. It is water-resistant and has a thicker, more pigmented formula that adheres well to the skin. It can withstand sweat, humidity, and even tears. Liquid eyeliner, while also long-lasting, can sometimes crack or flake off if not applied correctly.

Which is better for a natural look?

Liquid eyeliner is better for achieving a natural look. It creates a thin, precise line that looks more subtle and natural than the thicker and bolder line created by gel eyeliner. Liquid eyeliner is also easier to control, allowing you to create a natural-looking line without any mess.

Which is better for a dramatic look?

Gel eyeliner is better for creating a dramatic look. Its thick, pigmented formula allows for bold and striking lines that make a statement. Gel eyeliner is also easier to smudge, making it perfect for creating a smoky eye or a sultry, smudged liner look.

Which is better for a winged liner?

Both gel and liquid eyeliner can be used to create a winged liner. However, liquid eyeliner is usually better for this because of its precision brush or pen applicator. The thin, liquid formula allows for sharp and defined lines that can easily be extended into a wing.

Which is better for beginners?

Liquid eyeliner is usually better for beginners because of its easy-to-use pen or brush applicator. It allows for precise lines and easy control, making it perfect for those who are new to eyeliner application. Gel eyeliner requires more practice and skill to apply, and it can be more challenging for beginners to master.

Which is better for oily skin?

Liquid eyeliner is usually better for oily skin because of its fast-drying formula. It adheres well to the skin and stays in place all day, even on oily skin. Gel eyeliner can sometimes smudge or transfer on oily skin, especially if it is not set with powder.

Feature	Gel Eyeliner	Liquid Eyeliner
Consistency	Thick and creamy	Thin and runny
Application	Requires a brush or applicator	Comes with a fine brush or felt tip
Control	Offers more precision and control	Can be trickier to apply precisely
Finish	Matte finish	Glossy or shiny finish
Longevity	Longer lasting	Can smudge or fade quicker
Drying Time	Takes longer to dry	Dries quickly
Removal	Requires makeup remover	Easier to remove with just water
Variety of colors	Limited color options	Wide range of colors available
Suitability for skin	Best for oily skin or humid climates	Better for dry skin or cooler climates
Price	Generally more expensive than liquid	Generally less expensive than gel

Conclusion

In conclusion, both gel and liquid eyeliner have their advantages and disadvantages. Gel eyeliner is better for creating a dramatic look and lasts longer, while liquid eyeliner is better for achieving a natural look and is easier to apply. Ultimately, the choice between gel and liquid eyeliner depends on personal preference, skill level, and the desired look.

FAQs

Is gel or liquid eyeliner better for sensitive eyes?

Both gel and liquid eyeliner can be used for sensitive eyes, but it is essential to choose a formula that is hypoallergenic and gentle.

Can you use gel eyeliner on your waterline?

Gel eyeliner is not recommended for use on the waterline as it can irritate the eyes.

How do you prevent gel eyeliner from drying out?

To prevent gel eyeliner from drying out, make sure to close the lid tightly after use and store it upside down.

How do you remove gel eyeliner?

Gel eyeliner can be removed with an oil-based makeup remover or micellar water.

Can you use liquid eyeliner for a smoky eye?

While liquid eyeliner is not typically used for a smoky eye, it can be smudged with a brush or cotton swab to create a softer, smokier look.